Literature Circle Post #3: Describe a character who is a protector!

9/16/2013

Introduce your literature circle book and the author. Then describe one character who plays the role of "protector."

Address the following questions:

1. How is the protector tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters?

2. How is the protector tender toward his/her own weakness?

3. How does the protector PROTECT? State at least two examples that you've read about so far?

Remember to put your first name and the first initial of your last name. Also, DON'T FORGET to put your class period.

example: Shelia S., p. 1

102 Comments

Sandy Nhan Period 1

9/16/2013 11:32:36 am

I'm reading The Catcher In The Rye and I thought that Old Spencer was the protector.

1. Holden was a very lazy person who's always failing. Old Spencer decided to boost him up by talking to him alone.

2. Old Spencer is old so that was one of his weakness. He can't help and persuade Holden as much as he can. He can barely move!

3. He tried protecting Holden's grade by talking to him. Also, he didn't let Holden give up. He asked why, what's happening. He was one of the caring teacher.

Amanda C., p. 2

9/16/2013 01:18:21 pm

My literature circle book is "The Catcher in the Rye" by J.D. Salinger. The person who plays the protector is Mr. Spencer, Holden's history teacher at Pencey Prep.

1. Mr. Spencer is willing to take the time to ask Holden to go over to his house to talk to him about school.

2. Mr. Spencer tries to do his best for things.

3. Mr. Spencer took the time to invite Holden over to talk to him about school. He tried to get Holden to get back on track to do better for his future. Mr. Spencer also gave him a lecture on how he should do things by the rules.

Benjamin Trinh., Period 2

9/19/2013 02:16:31 am

Wow, I believe that Mr. Spencer is the protector of this book as well! He will probably help Holden succeed in life and is the only person that truly cares for him.

Cindy M., Period 6

9/17/2013 02:30:59 am

"Sold" is a novel by Patricia McCormick, published in 2006. The narrator of this story is Lakshmi who is a Nepali girl from a poor family. The book depicts the adventure of Lakshmi when she is sold into sexual slavery in India.

One of the protector of the novel is the American Customer #1. Unlike other customers who treat Lakshmi as a sexual slave, he pays Lakshmi without sleeping with her. Instead, he talks with her and tries to see if she wants to leave the Happiness House. When Lakshmi shuns him and responds nothing, the American Customer gives her a card which is the contact information.

Jiayuan (Amy) Z. Period 6

9/22/2013 04:30:12 am

American Customer #1 actually tried to understand Lakshmi's life and her hardships.

Eman Al-alami Per.2

9/17/2013 10:12:02 am

I am reading Catcher in the rye by J.D Salinger. I think the protector is Mr.Spencer.

1. He shows concern for Holden and his future. He puts his feelings of importance and helps him.

2. He uses his life stories to help Holden so he doesn't make the same mistakes.

3.He offered Holden hot chocolate and tells him good luck! He warns Holden to start caring about his future, he shows concern for him.

Mindy S., Period 6

9/17/2013 10:44:34 am

'The Help' was written by Kathryn Stockett who was very close to an African-American domestic worker. The Help is a book about two colored maids who worked for white families and tried to express the racism they experienced with the help of Ms. Skeeter. Eugenia "Skeeter" Phelan is a protector in the story.

1. Ms. Skeeter, though is a white daughter, she cares for her maids and disagree with all the racism issues.

2. Ms. Skeeter has her own problem. She wants to be a writer but her mother want her to get married. She applies for the job and gets to be a writer.

3. - Ms. Skeeter does not promote the restroom issue for Ms. Hilly on the Club newspaper.
- Ms. Skeeter tries to find out about Constantine ,her maid who got fired a long time ago. She saw Constantine as a family, as a person who raised her up, and as a person she can trust. She does not care about the different in races.

Rosakon C., Period 1

9/17/2013 11:39:12 am

My literature circle book is Sold by Patricia McCormick. This book is a story about a girl named Lakshmi who is trafficked into a brothel and forced to perform sexual favors in order to earn her way out. The character that I choose for the role of the protector is Shahanna. Shahanna is another girl who lives in the brothel (Happiness House) and helps Lakshmi cope with her surroundings.

1. When Lakshmi was new to the Happiness House, Shahanna showed empathy, guided Lakshmi, and explained the rules and order. She knew that Lakshmi was afraid and helped her cope with the environment.

2. Shahanna is tender toward her own weakness in that she obeys Mumtaz and turns a blind eye to the evils that happen to her.

3. Shahanna protects Lakshmi by giving her water when Lakshmi was locked in the room by herself to starve. Shahanna prevented Lakshmi from getting beaten by Mumtaz by instructing her how to handle customers.

Lewen M., Period 6

9/17/2013 02:38:09 pm

From the way you described Shahanna, she seems like a very compassionate girl. I'm glad there is someone like Shahanna to protect Lakshmi from the horrors of her situation in the brothel. This book reminds me of a Chinese drama series that I watched a few years ago. The main character had a similar situation to Lakshmi, and the main character was protected by an "older" sister in the brothel. The older sister's goal was to give the main character everything the older sister did not have so that the main character's life was better than the older sisters'. The older sister was the protagonists' protector just like how Shahanna is Lakshmi's protector.

Luwei T., Per. 6

9/18/2013 01:40:00 pm

Unlike Lewen I don't have a personal anecdote about this subject, but human trafficking is also of concern to me. It interests me how even in the thick of things there are people who care enough to protect others. I think this is a venerable tale of humanity and dignity. Surely those fallen victim to this have more to say and sacrifice than we do.

Yeah.

Do we have to do this? Its not in the post. >_>

Ryan H., Period 6

9/19/2013 11:41:55 am

I really love that Lakshmi has a protector. Her situation is extremely horrific, and having a protector makes it an innumerable amount of times better. This reminds me of the film Taken because I always think back to the daughter being kidnapped for sex trafficking. She did not have someone to care for her, and she easily could have been murdered. Lakshmi is very lucky to have Shahanna, and Lakshmi is forever indebted to her.

Michelle Z. Period 5

9/17/2013 01:48:22 pm

In "China Boy" by Gus Lee, Kai is constantly bullied by the tougher kids in his neighborhood. He joins the Y.M.C.A. where he is mentored by Mr. Barraza, a former professional boxer.
1. Mr. Barraza does not alienate Kai even though Kai is horrible at boxing. Instead, he focuses Kai on a program that will help him protect himself from the other kids and that will help him get stronger.
2. Mr. Barrraza is haunted by his past, where his promiscuity made his wife leave with their son. He misses his son, which causes him to care for the other boys in the Y.M.C.A. He knows that he will probably never see his son again, but he does not give up.
3. He gives Kai free food from the Y.M.C.A cafeteria in order to get stronger. He also tends to Kai's wounds, which happens very often since Kai is always getting beaten by the other kids.

Clara L, per 5

9/19/2013 04:22:41 am

Just by reading this, i am interested in reading this book already! i feel sad that the young generation have to go through the bullying when they suppose to live happily young. I believe that Mr. Barraza is a great influence to Kai, because he tried helping Kai every step of the way. Starting from improving his boxing skills patiently, to even see him and take care of him as his own son. His kindness will pay off by God. His generosity help change people's life, in specifically, Kai. I feel a warmth in my heart just by reading about this quick summary of this book, and can't wait to read it when i have the spare time doing so. Not only that Kai will change his life for the better, but he will help others that are going through the same thing he went through, when he grows old. He will be a role model to the younger generation, and teach them not to bully and learn self defense to the one that has to go through it.

Lewen M., Period 6

9/17/2013 01:50:20 pm

I am reading Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card. Valentine Wiggin is the epitome of a protector because all she wants to do is protect Ender Wiggin from their brother, Peter Wiggin. Valentine is Ender’s older sister and Peter’s younger sister. She has much of Ender’s compassion, but she is not ruthless like Peter.

1. Valentine is Ender’s protector. She never ceases to believe that Ender is the best of the Wiggin family. Valentine understands that Peter is ruthless and manipulative. When Ender was still living with his family, Valentine would protect Ender from Peter’s aggressive threats and attacks. Now that Ender is at Battle School, Valentine becomes Peter’s partner which shows that she overlooks their differences and attempts to make their relationship stronger.

2. Valentine works with Peter to transform the political system on earth by using her pseudonym Demosthenes. She does not want to manipulate people like how Peter creates fear in people. She knows that she is intelligent enough to make an impact without being too controlling. However, Valentine falls prey to the irresistible urge to power even though she would never wish to do damage in her attempt to change the world.

3. Valentine protects Ender no matter what; she loves Ender unconditionally. For example, when Ender took off his monitor, Peter was taunting Ender for not being good enough to attend Battle School. Valentine maintains by Ender’s side to comfort him while Peter throws hurtful words at them. Another instance of how Valentine is a protector is when she still celebrates Ender’s birthday even though her whole family gave up on Ender’s return to earth. Through Valentine, the memory of Ender is still alive on earth, and she is still hopeful that Ender will do great things.

Marjorie L., Period 5

9/17/2013 03:16:48 pm

The book I am reading now is THE HELP by Kathryn Stockett. One character who plays the role of "protector" is Ms. Skeeter.

1. Ms. Skeeter is white and unlike her other white friends Ms. Leefolt and Ms. Hilly, Ms. Skeeter has respect and compassion for the help. While her friends are trying to get all white families to build separate bathrooms for black employees, Ms. Skeeter goes behind their backs and writes a book containing stories of black women working for white families.

2. Writing this book is a huge risk for Ms. Skeeter. She would become a social outcast if her friends found out. Ms. Skeeter chooses to write about the lives of black maids because of her lost friend and maid Constantine.

3. After talking Ms. Hilly to getting separate bathrooms for black maids, Ms. Skeeter apologizes to Aibileen afterwards, knowing how disrespectful that talk was. Ms. Skeeter protects the black maids by writing a book revealing black women's lives working for white families.

Tyler F. Period 6

9/18/2013 02:10:50 pm

Wow. Ms. Skeeter seems like a woman out of her time. She would risk her reputation so that the African Americans would get recognition for what they do. She seems like a great protector and a great idealist because during her time, white people didn't really have respect or compasion for African people. Ms. Skeeter probably inspired many people to stand up for what they believe in.

Kayleigh Hennerty. Period 6

9/19/2013 04:12:25 pm

The Help seems like a great book! It definitely sounds like Ms. Skeeter was a protector. It's amazing how she was willing to risk her social standing to help the African Americans earn the respect they deserved. Back then it was so uncommon for whites to be friendly with African Americans because they just used them as maids or servants. It's nice that she has a friendship with her maid Constantine. I definitely want to read this book next :)

Vivian L., Period 5

9/18/2013 08:25:43 am

I'm reading "The Stranger" by Albert Camus. The book is about this man that gets caught into becoming a muderer for trying to help his friend. The character that portrays the protector is Marie, the mistress of Meursault.

1) Marie tries to help people in trouble or at least feel the need to. She gives Meursault motivation to keep going when he has given up. She sticks by his side even when he doesn't really appreciate it.

2) Marie's weakness is Meursault and she wants to be with him more than anything else. She desires to marry him, but he really doesn't care if they do. She tries to stay by his side in hopes that he
will finally see that she is perfect for him and he will marry her.

3) Marie tries to help this lady that was being abused by Raymond by telling Meursault to call the police, but Meursault didn't like the police. Marie also tried to help Meursault believe that he would get out of jail one day and they would go swimming again.

Xinyi Chen

9/18/2013 10:17:16 am

My literature circle book is "Sold" by Patricia McCormick. It talks about a girl -- Lakshmi was sold for sexual slavery.

1. The street boy is the protector of Lakshmi. He calm Lakshmi down and told her she's not alone, because he is with him.

2. The street boy tend to toward his weakness in that he lost his job for giving people free tea and other drinks.

3.He give Lakshmi coke when she feels bad even though Lakshmi didn't have money to pay. And when Lakshmi want alcohol, the street boy told her that it's not good for her.

Cindy M., Period 6

9/19/2013 01:43:45 pm

The street boy is one of my favorite characters in "Sold". I believe that the street boy's generosity toward Lakshmi has impressed every female reader. Shilpa said that Lakshmi might have fall in love with the street boy, and I agree with her. The scene in which Lakshmi hugged him when he left is the wamest scene in the novel.

Jasmine K. Period 6

9/18/2013 10:54:13 am

I am reading Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card. One character who plays the role "protector" is Alai. Alai was a member of Ender's launch group and they became best friends.

1. When Ender enters the battle school he is an outcast. No one really accepts him because he is better than the other students. Alai was the first to become friends with Ender and he helps him gain acceptance with other members of the school. Also his friendship with Ender prevents Ender from becoming depressed and instead, more motivated in the battle school.

2. Alai sticks to his values and culture throughout the story and does not change. He is able to be himself unlike other students who forget their values.

3. An example of how Alai protects is how he is on Ender's side and when Ender gets put down by some commanders, Alai is there for him and he believes in him. Another example is how Alai said that he will always be friends with Ender when Ender got moved up a rank.

Jiamin Li period 1

9/18/2013 10:57:06 am

'The Glass Castle' is a 2005 memoir by Jeannette Walls. One character who plays the role of "protector" is Brian, who is Jeannette's little brother.

1. Brian is the third of four children. He cares his family and help with his dad when the family get into trouble because he is the only son in the Wall family.

2. Brian is tender toward her own weakness in that he obeys to his father since he was too young to have position in the family.

3. Examples: Brian stood up for Jeannette when she was being beat, although he was even weaker and younger than Jeannette. and he helps Jeannette defend the siblings from local bullies.

Yongmin M., Period 6

9/18/2013 12:22:39 pm

The Cather in the Rye is a 1951 novel by J. D. Salinger. Originally published for adults, it has since become popular with adolescent readers for its themes for teenage angst and alienation.The novel is about a privileged yet troubled teen's take on life as he runs away from school to New York City. The narrator is Holden Caulfield. The events he narrates take place in the few days between the end of the fall school term and Christmas, when Holden is sixteen years old.

Jerome David Salinger was an American writer who won acclaim early in life. Very private for more than a half-century thereon, he last published an original work in 1965 and gave his final interview in 1980.

The protector of the novel is the narrator Holden Caulfield.

1. Holden wants to be the catcher in the rye by protecting children who may fall down the cliff.

2. Although Holden sometimes wants to act like an adult, he is extremely childish according to his behaviors. Since he thinks adults are disgusting, he really wants to to be a kid forever.

3. He wants to protect the kids who are playing in the field and avoid their falling down. He also wants to protect them by wishing them to be kids forever and being childish.

Luwei T., Per. 6

9/18/2013 01:31:41 pm

My Literature Circle book is The Book Thief, by Markus Zusak.

One character who plays the role of protector within The Book Thief is Hans Hubermann. Hans Hubermann, perhaps the most striking and clear-cut example of a protector within the book, is a security blanket and role model for Liesel and acts as a foil against the rougher characters of the book. Hans Hubermann is plainly shown to be a protector-type character when he firsts comforts Liesel near the very beginning of the book's events.

1. How is the protector tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters?
Hans Hubermann, unlike his wife Rosa Hubermann, actively comforts and protects Liesel from herself when she has nightmares at night. He does this every night, without regard to himself, no matter how much it inconveniences him. He cares nothing for this fault of hers or for himself and seeks only to make things right in his world.

His one fault might be that he does genuinely care little for his station in life (and his wife's opinions). He is comfortable just playing the piano accordion for money (which his wife finds intolerable). He doesn't have any ambition or drive to elevate himself, but he doesn't mind, himself.

His extremely selfless behavior toward Liesel is just one of the ways he is shown to be compassionate (although it is the main point toward this fact in the story). He also is forgiving when Liesel steals her first book and even trades her new books due to her interest in it. He also is the one who first teaches Liesel to read (yes, which is intricately connected with her theft of the book) which he does night after night with her after she has her nightmares.

Jiayuan (Amy) Z. Period 6

9/18/2013 01:33:12 pm

THE CATCHER IN THE RYE, by J.D. Salinger, accounts a story of Holden Caulfield, a student who had been dropped out of Pencey Prep during Christmas. In the story, narrator Holden Caulfield describes his relationship with his roommates, Stradlater, and Ackley. Holden leaves school two days early to explore New York before returning home, interacting with teachers, prostitutes, nuns, an old girlfriend, and his sister along the way. He also accounts his interaction with other people in the adult world. Through the story, the author exposes readers to the struggles faced by teenagers in their adolescence and the path of growing up and losing innocence.
In this story, Holden Caulfield can be considered a protector. He acts nice toward others’ weaknesses and becomes empathy of that person. He knows his weaknesses but he was not brave and encourages enough to make same change to his own weaknesses; thus, he chooses to avoid his weaknesses.
In the story, Holden Caulfield is a protector. Holden thought he could protect his brother, Allie, but he could not do anything because he brother died of leukemia. Holden greatly care for his sister Phoebe because he wants to protect Phoebe from the phony adult world.

Tyler F. Period 6

9/18/2013 02:05:02 pm

I am reading Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card. One protector in the story is Alai. Alai becomes friends with Ender and becomes the bridge between Ender and the other boys in their group.

1. Alai becomes a good friend of Ender even though he isn't "cool". Alai also helps Ender by shielding him from the bullies in their launch group. Alai also continuously pushes Ender to become a better strategist.

2. Alai knows that Ender is different and knows a lot about the battle room. By becoming friends with Ender, Alai is able to learn from Ender how to become a better soldier.

3. Alai protects Ender on a number of occasions. One example is when Ender is about to hit Alai in the battle room. Instead of taking the hit and getting in a fight, Alai helps Ender gain his balance and then their friendship begins to start. Another example would be when Ender gets transfered to an amry away from all his friends. Alai is there to comfort him and to tell him its ok. He gives Ender a hug and that helps Ender continue on his journey.

Chapman L., Period 6

9/21/2013 01:25:00 pm

Alai was a protector in Ender's Game that I overlooked. Alai seems to be like the great hero's first good friend and mentor in many heroic novels. They usually are the first one's there for the hero and mentor them until the hero surpasses them and takes the protector position for them.

Chapman L., Period 6

9/18/2013 04:03:48 pm

My literature circle book I'm reading is Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card. The protector I chose is Ender Wiggin.

1.Ender is the overall protector of the story, but it doesn’t really develop until the middle of the book.

2. He uses it as motivation to push himself to the limit and find ways to make up for them.

3. Ender protects his friend Shen from being bullied by Bernard. And also after Ender got promoted and started to teach his old launch groups maneuvers he learned from his army, Ender protected them from the other older boys that didn’t like Ender teaching the Launchies.

Jasmine K. Period 6

9/19/2013 04:55:59 pm

I agree with you on how Ender is the overall protector because he really does help many other launchies and the ability to protect the others. Ender is definitely the best and coolest character in the book. It's sweet how he protected Shen from being bullied. More people in reality need to learn how to be like Ender.

Stacie l , period 1

9/19/2013 12:58:07 am

In the book "Sold" by Patricia McCormick, one of the protector was Shahanna.

1. One of the main characters, Lakshmi, just arrived in the Happiness House. She was afraid and haven't adapted to the environment. Shahanna, having lived in the house for a very long time, shows Lakshmi around and guides her, offering her advice on all the characters.

2. One of the weakness Shahanna posses is Mumtaz. Although Shahanna knows a lot about Mumtaz, she is still under her authority. Shahanna still has no independence she can call hers.

3. One way Shahanna protects Lakshmi is that she was the first to offer water to Lakshmi after a few days. Another way shahanna protects Lakshmi is that she advices her around the house, advices her on the way she can survive , on how to get customers, on how to get the best tips. She tells her about the Americans who often come, and who the polices are, etc.

Adam D., Peroiod1

9/19/2013 01:04:36 am

My literature circle book that I'm reading is "Sold" by Patricia McCormick. I believe the protector in the story is a character named Shahanna.

1. Shahanna is tender toward the character Lakshmi by catering to her weaknesses such as Lakshmi being fairly new to the "happiness house," and by giving her advice on the does and don'ts of the house.

2.Shahanna also sees her own weakness by realizing there is no way out of the happiness house for her. Therefore, she is complacent and compliant to the owner of the house, Mumtaz's, authority.

3. Shahanna protects the main character Lakshmi during her captivity in the happiness house by teaching her how to conduct herself while she is there. In addition to helping Lakshmi adjust to the happiness house she also warns her about the dangers of Americans and how they can earn her a spot of humiliation with Mumtaz's goondas.

Victoria Y. Period 1

9/20/2013 04:03:09 am

I have a character in my book that is very similar to Shahanna. Im reading Catcher in the Rye and the main chracter, Holden Caulfield, also tries to give advice to others.

Jimmy Nguyen,per 1

9/19/2013 01:12:30 am

Illustrator-This week my job is to be the illustrator and for the book "Tweak" by Nicsheff I drew one of the main character smoking and taking drugs at his friends house.

Jacqueline W., Period 1

9/19/2013 01:16:05 am

1. How is the protector tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters?
The protectors for "Sold" in this section were Shahanna and the little tea boy who brings tea to the Happiness House every day. Shahanna and the little tea boy were more benevolent to Lakshmi than the others because they all provided her information, care, and comfort in what she has to call a "home".

2. How is the protector tender toward his/her own weakness?
Shahanna understands that her debt to Mumtaz won't be paid until many more years, yet she acts like everything is okay. Her weakness is that, like all the other girls, Mumtaz is in charge of the girls in the house and regulates their money, so no matter how much Shahanna would like to help others like Lakshmi, she needs to focus on herself if she wants to get out of the Happiness House anytime soon. In addition, the little tea boy gives Lakshmi free tea even though he knows his boss counts every tea and every change given back so he takes the beating when he is missing some change.

3. How does the protector PROTECT? State at least two examples that you've read about so far?
Whenever Lakshmi was questioning something, Shahanna was always there to help answer Lakshmi's questions. Shahanna also keeps all of Lakshmi's secrets and guides Lakshmi a way to cope with the dirty men that go to the Happiness House. And whenever the little tea boy came by the house to sell tea to the women, Lakshmi would turn away because she didn't want to waste any money on anything else, but the little tea boy would offer to give Lakshmi free tea.

Victoria Y. Period 1

9/19/2013 01:23:29 am

I am reading Catcher in the Rye and one protector in this story is Holden Caulfield.

1. He treats them kindly, but he feels sorry for them. Sometimes he gives to people because he has pity for them, but other times its genuine.

2. He knows he doesn't have that much cash on him and he tries to help the less fortunate. He tried to give more even when it wasn't required or asked for. He has a weakness for those who are less fortunate.

3. In one part of the story he tries to buy two nuns breakfast. Although they refuse he tries to help in some other way. Holden then donates $10 to their charity services even though he knows he doesn't have money left. Another time is when he buys his little sister a record. He knows she would love the music so he gets her a gift.

kelly cuadra period 2

9/19/2013 02:15:17 am

The book we are reading is "Sold" by Patricia McCormick. The protector in this story is Shahanna because when Lakshmi was new to the brothel she helped her and showed her what she can and cant do. She helped her withe the rules and regulations so she wont get in trouble and get beaten from Mumtaz. Although she goes through a lot of hardships because of Mumtaz she manages to try to keep it under control. She helps Lakshmi survive instead of having hate towards her.

Benjamin Trinh., Period 2

9/19/2013 02:15:26 am

I am reading The Catcher In The Rye by J.D. Salinger. The protector that i choose is Mr. Spencer.

1. Mr. Spencer is the protecter because he is constantly helping Holden before he leaves the school. He is the only one that truly cares for him.

2. Mr. Spencer is tender towards Holden because he is always giving Holden helpfully life advice. He is truly the only one that cares about Holden.

3.Mr. Spencer protects by giving him advice on how to live life. With these advices he helps him move on with his life. He gave Holden lessons on how to improve his life choices. Another example was when Me. Spencer gave Holden a lecture on life. Holden seriously needs this.

Cindy Tran Period 2

9/19/2013 02:20:11 am

My literature circle book is "Tweak" by Nic Sheff and the protector that I chose is Gack.

1. Gack is the one who sells the drugs to Nic, but he doesn't just sell it to him he does it with him. Later on they do become friends and Gack seems to know more about the whole drug life than Nic does so he sort of looks out for Nic and makes sure that Nic doesn't get into too much trouble.

2. Gack knows that he has a problem, but he uses it to his advantage. He helps other worth their way around their own addictions, like Nic, and shows them how they can do it without harming others and just to do it for the satisfaction of their own self.

3. Gack protects Nic by being by his side a lot throughout the book. At first Nic doesn't trust him, but later on Gack does return back with the drugs in exchange for the wad of cash that Nic gave him. Someone like Gack may seem like someone to scam you, but he didn't. He brought Nic to his house with his dad and guided him the way to be calm.

Kristyn G per2

9/19/2013 02:22:05 am

1. In the Help the protector Ms. Skeeter is tender towards the black ladies she put in her book by trying to comfort their fears of being hurt if they got discovered. Ms. Skeeter is also very patient and doesn't push the story out of them.
2. To herself she tries to keep herself from Stuart her (ex)boyfriend and the ladies of The League so she cannot be persecuted by them.
3. She lies to her mother about being with Stuart after they broke up because she is afraid of her mother being more worried about her not getting married. She also protects the ladies in her book by changing their names and where it takes place.

Clara L, per 5

9/19/2013 04:33:35 am

I am reading " Tweak " by Nic Sheff. The character in this book who i think is a protector, is Spencer.

1. Spencer is nic's sponsor. He helped Nic by convincing him to go back to L.A and start a new life and that he will help him find a place to stay and get away from his destruction and addiction to drugs.

2. Spencer knows how Nic feels, and he encourages Nic by making him laugh and see the positive side of life if he starts changing his ways. He also has been through what Nic is going through, so he knows that everything takes time and he is willing to help Nic every step of the way.

3. Spencer helped protect Nic because he convinced Nic to fly to L.A and he paid for the tickets so that Nic wont change his mind. He also find Nic a place to stay, and work with Nic daily. He has a lot of patience and he is very encouraging. He has a lot of things in common with Nic, which makes Nic's step to a new life a bit more easier.

Kevin T., Period 5

9/19/2013 05:59:47 am

My book is the "Ender's Game" by Orson Scott Card.
Colonel Graff is one of the protectors in the book.

1. Since he has control over much of the computer and monitor systems, he is fully aware of the weakness of his students throughout the book. He tries to help his students to overcome their weaknesses all the time.

2. He recognizes that some of his students are wiser, smarter than him, but he does not show that.

3. a. He attacked another student on the space shuttle to establish reputation for Ender.
b. He hid the fact that Ender killed two people from his fights.

Clarissa H. period 5

9/19/2013 05:59:48 am

I am reading The Glass Castle by Jeanette Walls. In her memoir, she tells the story of her life growing up and how she was influenced through the people surrounding her. I believe that her younger brother Brian was a very positive influence in her life because of his PROTECTOR attitude.

1. How is the protector tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters?
Brian is the only son in his family and feels the need to protect them because their Dad is an alcoholic. He knows that his father doesnt have the willpower to stop drinking so he takes it upon himself to look after the others.

2. How is the protector tender toward his/her own weakness?
Although Brian is a protector of the family, he still cannot disobey his father because he is too young to overcome him.

3. How does the protector PROTECT? State at least two examples that you've read about so far?
After Jeanette comes home from a fight with a gang of girls, he takes it upon himself to confront them and even fight. He also defends their home from a group of boys who want to pick a fight and make fun of their family for being poor.

Jeny C., Per.5

9/22/2013 11:26:15 am

I am too reading THE GLASS CASTLE. However, although Brian is considered a protector in the story, I believe that Jeannette is a much more prominent protector!

Jin C. Period 5

9/19/2013 06:09:05 am

In the book "Ender's Game" by Orson Scoot Card, Valentine is the protector and the person who she protects is Ender.

1. Valentine protects Ender whenever Peter is around. She loves Ender more than Peter.

2. Later on in the book when she tried to change the system on earth, she finds out that liking of control over things and that's where things change later on.

3. She protects Ender from Peter whenever she cans. Valentine also later on helps everyone one earth to change the harsh political system on earth.

Victoria L., Period 5

9/19/2013 06:23:47 am

In "China Boy" by Gus Lee, Kai is constantly bullied by other kids in the neighborhood. Touissant was Kai's only friend.
1. He helped Kai understand the life on the streets.
2. He invited Kai to his home where his mother would treat Kai with kindness.
3. Touissant helped make Kai's life better than it previously was.

Cynthia L. period 5

9/19/2013 06:30:22 am

My literature circle book is "Ender's game " by Orson Scott Card
the protector to me has always been Valentine.

1. Valentine adores Ender and cares deeply about him. So every time
Peter attempts to attack or talk bad about Ender she always defends him and calls him out on it. She also defends anyone else who Peter tries to attack like since Peter think he is a genius he makes fun of "stupid people" Valentine always has something good to say.

2. Valentine , although she defends Ender she is very scared of Peter. She fears him deeply because he is always tells her he's gonna kill her She stands up to him but she is in reality not willing to go far she holds herself back on a lot of things. So that is her quality she
3. When Peter was plotting something , Valentine came in and disrupted his scheme.
Another example was when valentine and Ender

Alex K. Period 6

9/19/2013 06:59:46 am

I am reading "Sold" by Patricia McCormick and one protector was the American Man.

1. The American Man is tender to Lakshmi because he knows she is scared and trapped in the Happiness House. He tries to calm her down and get her out of the house.

2. He can be captured by Mumtaz if she wanted to, but he took the risk to go into the Happiness House pretending to be a customer and free the girls that she has locked up.

3. The American Man went out of his way to try to get Lakshmi out of the house and into a better life but he wasn't able to the first time. He came back later and revealed Mumtaz for her crimes and freed all the girls.

Chanel L., Peroid 6

9/19/2013 07:01:02 am

I am reading "The Help" By Kathryn Stockett. This story is about colored maids working for white families. Ms. Skeeter doesn't agree with how some of the white families thinks colored people should have different bathrooms. The protector I choose is Ms. Skeeter.

1. Ms. Skeeter who comes from a white family grew up with a colored maid who took care of her. She doesn't agree with all the racism going on.

2. Ms. Skeeter has always wanted to be a writer, but her mother stops her from living her own dream. But she takes over and gets a job to be a writer. Also even though she listens to Ms. Hilly about the whole bathroom situation, she never agrees with her.

3. -Ms. Skeeter doesn't listen to Ms. Hilly about promoting the bathroom issue on the Club magazine.
- When Ms. Skeeter is writing her book she protects her characters by changing their names. That way no one will know and cause trouble.

Ronald H. Period 6

9/19/2013 07:06:44 am

I am reading "Sold" by Patricia McCormick. The protector is American Man #3.

1. The American Man #3 talked to Lakshmi of how bad this place is and that Mumtaz cannot force anyone to do this kind of stuff.

2. The American Man #3 fear that Mumtaz will find out that he talked to Lakshmi about getting her out of the "Happiness House".

3. The American Man #3 told Lakshmi that he will help her get out of "Happiness House". He told her to wait for him to come back. The American Man came back with polices to arrest Mumtaz and save Lakshmi.

John H. Per.5

9/22/2013 12:01:30 pm

From what you explain about how the American Man #3 aided others, I feel that he really is a protector. It is great how some people would take time out of their lives and help others like how the American Man called the police to help save Lakshmi.

Qinfu G. (Ken), Period 6

9/19/2013 07:17:05 am

I am reading "The Catcher in the Rye" by J.D. Salinger. The protector I chose is Mr. Spencer.

1) In "The Catcher in the Rye", Mr. Spencer is one of those teacher that wishes for their student to succeed. He have tried to help many students including failures like Holden.

2) Mr. Spencer gave Holden chances to not drop out but he does anyway. He tried to give Holden times to finish his assignment but he doesn't.

3) Mr. Spencer lectures Holden, trying to set him on the right path. Even though he knows that Holden is going to be dropping out and become a failure, he did not give up on him and continuous to help him. "Do you have any particular qualms about leaving Pencey?"

Kami T. Period 1

9/19/2013 07:36:58 am

My literature circle book that I'm reading is "Sold" by Patricia McCormick. I believe that the protector in the story is Shahanna.

1. Shahanna was more tender toward Lakshmi than others because when Lakshmi was new to the "happiness house" she treated her better and cared for her. She stood by Lakshmi's side when she was ill and emotionally ill. Shahanna provided Lakshmi with care, company, and advice.

2. Shahanna understands that her debt to Mumtaz won't be paid until many more years, just like every other girl working for Mumtaz. Since Mumtaz is in charge at regulating the girls money, she has all the power over them. Shahanna's weakness is that she would like to help others, like Lakshmi, but she has to focus on paying off her own debt, so she could leave the happiness house and go back home.

3. Shahanna protects Lakshmi by teaching her how to cope with the dirty men that come to the happiness house. She also tells Lakshmi everything she knows about the danger that could happen if you try to run away and how dangerous some of the Americans could be. Shahanna also kept Lakshmi's secrets.

Xinyi C. Period 5

9/19/2013 08:44:58 am

Brandon F., Period 1

9/19/2013 08:59:02 am

"Sold" by Patricia McCormick - The protector I chose was Shahanna
1. How is the protector tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters?
When Lakshmi, the protagonist, arrives at the Happiness House, a prostitution hotspot, Shahanna, a girl who worked in the kitchen, sympathized with her because she was lost and confused. She told Lakshmi what she needed to know in order to survive under the tight watch of their owner. She also gave her condoms, which would prevent Lakshmi from contracting any venereal disease.

2. How is the protector tender toward his/her own weakness?
Mumtaz is in charge of all the girls in the Happiness House and possesses their earnings from prostitution. Shahanna realizes that her debt to Mumtaz will not be paid off any time soon; still, she remains headstrong.

3. How does the protector PROTECT? State at least two examples that you've read about so far?
Throughout the story, Shahanna offered advice for Lakshmi on how to make her stay at the Happiness House less dreary; she told Lakshmi of Mumtaz's deal with law enforcement and other secrets. She also has provided her with tea, candies, and condoms.

Henry G., Period 5

9/19/2013 10:06:10 am

I am reading "The Stranger" by Albert Camus. This story talks about the life of Monsieur Meursault after his mother's funeral. In my opinion, the protector in this story would most likely be Marie, Meursault's lover.

1. Marie acted as a way for Meursault to take his mind off his mother's death by spending time with her. Marie also spends quality time with Meursault to improve their relationship.

2. Marie wants to be loved so she wanted to spend more time with Meursault to improve their relationship together in hope that they will eventually marry in the future.

3. In the book, when Raymond was hitting his girlfriend, Marie told Meursault to notify the authorities to settle the problem. During Meursault's time in jail, Marie tried her best to support Meursault in any way she can.

Ryan H., Period 6

9/19/2013 11:38:05 am

I am currently reading Ender's Game, a science fiction novel by American author Orson Scott Card. Card has lived and continues to live in Greensboro, North Carolina where much of Ender's Game is influenced by. It was a short story originally before Card expanded it. Ender's Game Set in Earth's future, a military school finds and trains fleet commanders to fight against "buggers," a deadly alien insect species, from taking over Earth. Ender Wiggin is the protagonist who is prophesied as the future hero of Earth. As Ender goes through his journey, He meets Alai, a fellow Battle School soldier, who becomes a protector.

1. Ender is hated amongst the other kids of the Battle School because he is the most gifted of them all. He gets slightly bullied and does not have any friends. Alai befriends him, comforting Ender and making it more comfortable for Ender to be himself. This allows Ender to grow as a commander.

2. Alai is a very talented fleet commander himself, but Ender is a better strategist. He, the better fighter, teaches Ender combat while Ender guides Alai in what plans to use as attack.

3. When Ender seemingly had no friends, Alai played a game with Ender to help change the other kids' attitudes toward Ender. This allowed for Ender to be approved by the boys and put him in a better situation. Second, Ender cried when he found out he had to transfer, and Alai comforted and hugged him. He whispered in his ear to tell him he would be okay, and this reminded Ender of his mother. Alai is a symbol of family for Ender at the Battle School, and he is comforting for Ender, allowing him to move on.

Karishma Bhakta p.2

9/19/2013 12:35:40 pm

The Book Thief by Markus Zusak

The Protector is Hans Hubermann. He is the father of Leisel and he has no job and plays the accordion to comfort Leisel. Hans is a patient and understanding man. He tends to ignore his wife's mean comment. He tries to earn money by taking small jobs by playing music at clubs. He does not want to be in the Nazi party. He protects Leisel by warning her and comforting her during her nightmares. Leisel figured our that Hitler was the reason she lost her family. After the book burning on Hitler's birthday, she screams that she hates Hitler. Hans warns her to not say that she hates Hitler in public but she can say it at home. Hans also protects Leisel during her nightmares. He comes to hug and read their book together, no matter how tired Hans may be. Hans is a great protector and father.

Dolores Resendiz Period 1

9/19/2013 01:04:53 pm

I'm reading "The Stranger" by Albert Campus. The protector in this novel is Marie Cardona.

1. Marie is tender toward the feelings of other characters specially Mersault when he is imprisoned and is awaiting trial. She stays faithful to him and is seen as a blessing.

2. Marie Cardona, is tender towards mersaults weakness by marring him because he is 'in love' although it is not shown that her intentions were clear because she also enjoyed that he wasn't so intrigued by her life when they were apart. Marie stays faithful to Mersault and she never gives up home on him. His weakness being the want of freedom at a point.

3. Marie protected when she asked Mersault to go check what is going on in the room next door where Raymond is with his mistress. she asks him to call the police, but Mersault refuses.
Another Example would be when she visits Mersault in prison, i believe at this point she protecting him by keeping him sane while he awaits trial.

Fandi Wang Period 1

9/19/2013 01:19:27 pm

I am reading The Catcher In The Rye by J.D. Salinger. The protector that I chose is Old Spencer.

1.) Old Spencer tried to help Holden by talking to him and preventing him to fail his classes.
2.) Old Spencer's weakness was that he can't help Holden as much as he wants to because he has his limits
3.) Old Spencer protects Holden by giving him advice on life.Another example was when Old Spencer gave a talk about his grades, trying to protect him from failing.

Benjamin F. P.5

9/19/2013 01:49:05 pm

I am reading "The Help" by Kathryn Stockett.

1) I believe Mrs. Skeeter is the protector. She tends to the maid by voicing their opinions in her book about working for a white family. She also tends to them by being colored blind and not be racist to them.

2) Mrs. Sketter knows that she is freakishly tall and not that attractive but she still tries her best, to look her best, and find herself a good man.

3) Mrs. Skeeter protected the maid by not publishing Mrs. Hilly's opinion on black diseases and them using a colored toilet. She also protected the colored maid by changing their names in her book sop they don't get in trouble for telling their stories.

Dylan N., Period 5

9/19/2013 01:52:41 pm

The book, "The Stranger" by Albert Camus is about a man that is influenced into becoming a murderer for attempting to support his friend.I think the protector in this book is Marie, the mistress of Meursault.

1) Marie helps people whenever she sees trouble. She tells Meursault not to look down while he should not give up. She stays side by side even when she knows she is not appreciated by Meursault.

2) Marie's weakness is Meursault and she wants to be with him more than anything else. She wants to marry him, but Meursault is careless about it. She attempts to do whatever it takes to open Meursault's eyes and convince him to marry her.

3) Marie, as a protector, protects Meursault by helping him in everyway, such as when he got arrested for killing a man, she visited him and gave him her words. She also helped Meursault by telling him that she loves him, even though he doesn't care, he knows that Marie is right beside him

Wilson T. , Tak N. Period 5

9/19/2013 02:39:28 pm

I am reading "Ender's Game" by Orson Scott Card. This week, our job is the connector. In the book Ender's game, Ender Wiggin is promoted from a launchie to a soldier in one of the armies. First he is put in Salamander army, which the leader and him don't get along with. There are members who do cooperate but basically Ender is pushed out and singled out. This is related to group work in school. Sometimes you don't get a group you can work with and like Ender, have to practice yourself. But then he gets traded to Rat army which cooperation and teamwork is stressed to win the game. So in his toon, the leader tries to incorporate him in the group just like a good group would do.

Kristi L. Period 5

9/19/2013 03:09:13 pm

In the book "The Help" by Kathryn Stockett, Ms. Skeeter would be the protector in the story.

1. Ms. Skeeter is very kind even to the help. She doesn't treat them as if they are any different from all the whites in the town. She treats them equally and she treats them like family if they are close.

2. Ms. Skeeter has many problems of her own. She is lectured by her mother more than enough times. She wants to become a writer but the mother does not approve. And to add on to that, her mother bugs her about getting a boyfriend which only puts more stress in her.

3. Ms. Skeeter did not put the article, about having separate restrooms than blacks, into the newspaper. She also wrote stories about people's experiences as the help so people would understand what they go through.

Wilson T. Period 5

9/19/2013 03:11:50 pm

I am reading "Ender's Game" by Orson Scott Card. The protector I chose is Valentine Wiggin.

1. Valentine only protects the main character Ender Wiggin, and she is very caring towards him. When Ender is getting violently thrashed around by his brother Peter Wiggin, she steps in to negotiate and talk Peter out of doing so. She also knows Ender more than anyone else, but still does not know everything about him.
2. Valentine's weakness is that she is too soft and kind. What she does to counteract this weakness is by being so smart in her debating and negotiating that the opponent has to agree with her because of her common sense. So she uses her intelligence to hide her handicap.
3. Valentine protects by protecting Ender from Peter's wraith. In one scene of "Ender's Game", Valentine shows Ender what she had to endure because she stepped in and disrupted Peter's fun. Another time was when Ender fell into deep depression and mourning after a few years in battleschool. Valentine provides counseling and guidance to him.

Lisa D., Period 5

9/19/2013 03:27:52 pm

China Boy by Gus Lee. The protector is Toussaint LaRue (Nicknamed Toos)

1) Toos is the first kid to be nice to Kai in the neighborhood. He takes Kai under his wing and gives him pointers on how to survive on the streets. He offers Kai friendship and shares his mother's warmth with Kai. Toos does not like to bully the weak and only fights when reason does not suffice.

2) Toos is from a poor family and his father had died in WWII. He is not bitter about not having money for luxuries and plays it cool when Kai asks him to join the Y, which charges a monthly fee. Toussaint tends to be a father figure to the children in the neighborhood.

3) Toos protected Kai on the first day Kai was beaten by the kids of the neighborhood. He lightly punched Kai's arm so that the other kids wouldn't keep hitting him.
Toos also tries to protect the smaller children on the neighborhood and asks only one favor of Kai: Do not raise fists to a child.

Stanley Yang(Youwei) Period 6

9/19/2013 03:31:15 pm

The literature circle book I am reading is “Ender’s Game” by Orson Scott Card. One of the protector in the book is Valentine, Ender’s sister.
1. Valentine tend to find Peter, Ender’s older brother, weakness. Such as scaring him with things like going to jail.
2. Valentine tend to hide her own weakness, and she tend to not get into the fight.
3. When Peter is bullying Ender, Valentine stop Peter by threaten him that he can go to jail and never meet his dream if he really kill Ender and Valentine.

Nicole G., Period 6

9/19/2013 03:58:27 pm

I'm reading Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card, and the character I chose that enacts the role of "protector" is Ender Wiggin.

1) Ender recognizes weaknesses in other characters or relates to them when they are treated as lesser beings, and he empathizes with them by trying to make light of the situation. Or at the least, he doesn't continue to pour salt into the wound(s).

2) Ender is tender towards his own weaknesses because he knows when he's afraid and when he's angry/unhappy, but he chooses to ignore them. He doesn't want to look weak in front of others, even though he's only so young.

3) Examples of Ender doing the protecting include: 1. the time Shen was bullied by Bernard, and Ender stood up for Shen by retaliating against Bernard. 2. when the Launchies were being harassed by older kids or commanders, Ender wanted to quit his extra lessons with them. He didn't want to drag the innocent kids down with him and told them they should just quit their daily lessons.

Kayleigh Hennerty. Period 6

9/19/2013 04:05:24 pm

I am reading Catcher in the Rye. In my reading so far, I think Old Spencer is the protector.

1. The main character Holden, has been failing his way out of almost every school he has attended. Old Spencer wanted to help Holden stay at Pencey so he tried talking some sense into him. Unfortunately, Old Spencer wasn't able to convince Holden to do his work and to stay focused.

2. I think one of Spencer's weaknesses was his age. When Holden went to say bye to him at his house, Old Spencer couldn't even get out of his chair. Holden described him as weak and fragile looking. I think that was one of the reasons why he couldn't persuade Holden as much as he wish he could have. He didn't have the strength or energy to continue to push him.

3. Old Spencer tried protecting Holden in many ways. First, while he was at Pencey, Spencer offered to help Holden with his assignments and even passed him on things he should've failed. Spencer didn't want Holden to get kicked out of Pencey. The second reason that shows he's a protector is when Holden goes to his house to say good bye. Spencer is a little harsh with Holden and scolds him for what he's done. Old Spencer didn't mean to be rude with Holden, but he wanted to show that he cared and he didn't want Holden to fall into the same habits. He wants Holden to succeed in life and he makes it clear to him.

Matthew Salazar

9/19/2013 04:06:42 pm

In reading "The Catcher in the Rye" by J.D. Salinger. The protector is Mr. Spencer.

1. Mr.Spencer was Holdens old teacher at Pency. Mr.Spencer shows his tenderness towards Holden by trying to give him passing grades and caring for his future.

2. Mr.Spencer tells Holden about his past experiences so he doesn't make similar mistakes.

3.He helps Holden by give him advice for what to do with his life so he does not end up a failure.

Zhi D., Period 1

9/19/2013 04:11:21 pm

I am reading "The Glass Castle" by Jeannette Walls. This book is about Jeannette's childhood, and her stories and experience of moving around with her family.

The protector in this book is Brian.
1)Brian helps Jeannette defend the people that are hurting Jeannette or the time that Jeannette needs help. Even know Brian is younger than Jeannette, he always stand up for her and take care her.
2) Brian is the only son and younger than Jeannette, he should be the one that Jeannette should take care but Brian still stands up for her every time she is hurt.
3)Brian protect Jeannette by when she is being beat, Brian stands up for her. Another example will be he helps Jeannette defend the siblings from local bullies.

Tommy C., Period 5

9/19/2013 04:14:44 pm

In THE HELP by Kathryn Stockett, Aibileen is a protector of Mae Mobley and her fellow maiden friends.

1.) Aibileen does not manipulate others' weakness to her advantage; instead, she strives to help others meet their needs. Aibileen is compassionate towards others who live under the same restrictions in life as she does and tries to sympathize with those people she can trust.

2.) Aibileen tends to her own weakness by agreeing to help Miss Skeeter write her book. Aibileen struggles to contain her contempt for the racial discrimination; however, by helping Miss Skeeter write the book, Aibileen now has a procedure where she can vent all the complaints and criticism about the whites.

3.) Aibileen is both caring and compassionate for the people she loves. Aibileen provides Mae Mobley with the maternal love Miss Leefolt, Mae Mobley's mother, neglects to show. Whenever Mae Mobley is in need, Aibileen will do whatever she can in order to pamper the child, treating Mae Mobley as her very own daughter. Minny, who maintains a sassy attitude toward her bosses, tends to talk back to her employers. Because of her rebellious behavior, Minny, has trouble finding a willing employer to hire her; however, with the persistent assistance from Aibileen, Minny learns to correct her improper behavior.

Kathy F. Period 1

9/19/2013 04:52:05 pm

The literature circle book that I am reading is " The Book Thief" by Markus Zusak. I protector that I chose is Hans Hubermann.

1) Hans Hubermann is a protector. In times where Liesel is feeling down and unsatisfied with herself, he is always there to aid her and make her feel important.

2) He is sleepy during the night, but he puts his own weakness and issues aside to help Liesel.

3) He is a protector by being there for people. He is always there for Liesel when she has nightmares. Hans Hubberman also is there for Max; when Max showed up, Hans did not chose to shy away from his promise, but to respect it and protect Max with his home and his family.

Chris (Jae) E., Period 5

9/20/2013 01:14:30 am

In the book, "The Help," written by Kathryn Stockett, Ms skeeter turns out to play the role of protector.

1. Miss Skeeter is a very kind white lady who opposes the separate restrooms for the help. She has respect and compassion to change the world for the help and writes a book about the helps behind her white friends.

2. Writing this book is a huge risk for herself. She would become a huge social outcast if she were to be caught by her friends or other white people. She decided to write a book because she lost a friend and maid named Constantine.

3. Miss Skeeter apologizes to Aibileen after the talk with Ms. Hilly about the separate restrooms for the black maids. Miss Skeeter tries to protect the black maids by writing a book about how African American maids work for white families.

My T. Period 2

9/20/2013 05:07:36 am

I am reading Sarah's Key by Tatiana de Rosnay. Two examples of protectors in this book are Jules and Genevieve.

1) When Sarah and Rachel escape from the camp, they are shunned away by the people they met. However, when Jules and Genevieve discover them in their farm one day, they take them into their house, and give them food and shelter.

2) When the police come to their farm after they discover Jules and Genevieve are housing Jews, the old couple are very scared. However, they are able to calm themselves down, and avoid being arrest.

3) Jules and Genevieve help Sarah to return to Paris to find her brother who is hiding in the cupboard. After finding that her brother is already dead, the old couple take Sarah in like their own daughter who they never have. She stays with them for about 10 years, and afterward, she leaves for America to leave behind her painful past.

Tatiana C. Period 5

9/20/2013 07:40:37 am

I'm reading the help by Kathryn Stockett. I think Ms. Skeeter is the protector.

1) Ms. Skeeter is the protector because she kept in secret that the maid is giving her the information she needs to published her story.

2) She is very and she has no preference toward white or black she treats everyone as equal.

3) She is not agree with Hilly's ideas to have a separate restroom for colored people,

Lillian Lin, Period 5

9/20/2013 11:53:22 am

My literature circle book is "Sold" by Patricia Mccormick, published in 2006. The story is about the narrator Lakshmi, a poor girl from Nepal, was sold different times, and eventually became a victim of sexual slavery. One of the protector in this book is Ama, Lakshmi's mother.

1. Even though woman have extremely low social status in Nepal, Ama tries to take best care of Lakshmi and his brother. When Lakshmi's stepfather wants to make Lakshmi go to the city and work as a maid in the first time, Ama strongly refused and insisted that Lakshimi should go to school.

2. One weakness of Ama is that she is too docile. She obeys the rules in her society and order of her husband attentively.

3. One example, as I stated in question 1, is that Ama tries to protect Lakshmi from taken away from school. Another example that demonstrates Ama protect peole around her is that when there was a drought, and the money they have was scarce. Ama sells away her earings, which may mean something vital to her since she wore them eveyday, for exchange of some food and water.

Rainie X., Per 1

9/20/2013 12:55:05 pm

The literature circle book that I am reading is "The Glass Castle", by Jeannette Walls. I think the protector is Brain.

1. Brain is the only son in the Walls family. Although he is the second youngest, he always try his best to help his parents and sisters. He shows his care and love when his family gets into trouble. When Jeannette was in trouble, he was the one that most likely to help her.

2. Brain's weakness is that he can not always be there, and he is too young. Sometimes, he can not even protect himself. For example, when Grandma Erma tried to doing something that she should not do to him( Grandma Erma is pervert), he could not even

Matthew Salazar., Period 6

9/22/2013 03:05:23 pm

Brain seems like a protector in the making. Since he is young, he doesn't have the ability or strength to protect himself or his family. It's said that his grandma would try to do terrible things to him. I'm sure as he gets older he'll realize all that happened to him and it'll make him a better protector to his own family.

Natasha Nix p.6

9/20/2013 01:37:56 pm

The book I am reading is The Book Thief by Markus Zusak and I chose Hans Hubermann as my Protector

1. Hans takes other people's feeling into consideration and doesn't judge anyone. He does his best make people feel better when things are hard.

2. Hans really puts himself last after everyone. He always puts Liesel before his needs and always helps her when she needs it. So to me, it really seems that he doesn't really matter to himself.

3. Hans acts as the protector with Liesel and Max. He protects Liesel by comforting her when she had nightmares and wet the bed the times she did. He always stays up with her at night as well. He protects Max by helping him with his hiding. When Max came to his door, Hans did not shut the door in his face or turn him down. He let Max in with open arms and offered his assistance with whatever he could give.

Anita Z., Period 06

9/20/2013 03:46:23 pm

SOLD by Patricia McCormick.
Protector of the story—Shahanna

1. Shahanna becomes close friends with Lakshmi from the very beginning. She helps Lakshmi get accustomed to her new life at the Happiness House. She warns her about Mumtaz and the customs she had to face in order to survive.
2. Since Mumtaz is in charge, Shahanna is faced to obey her orders serving men and earning rupees in order to survive.
3. Shahanna protects throughout the story by offering advice and news towards Lakshmi about protecting herself with condoms, warning her about getting the virus. She would always stay besides her, ever since the first day. She tells her about the Americans and the police men as well. Everything she needed to survive and stay out of trouble was mentioned to her.

Brian Kaw Per 6

9/20/2013 04:12:45 pm

In the book, "Ender's Game" by Orson Scoot Card, Valentine is one of the various protectors of this this book as she protects Ender.

1. She acts as a protector times such as when he protects Ender from Peter as she loves ender more than peter even though they are siblings.

2. As I continue in this book, as she finds various ways to protect ender not only from peter but also from those in his battle school, she finds a interesting theory in the world that she wants to distribute which acts as the protector of the world by this discovery.

3. Not only does Valentine protect ender, but she also tries her best to change the view of the world's politics as she finds it totalitarian like and undemocratic as well as injustice.

Judy U. period 5

9/20/2013 04:56:20 pm

I am reading "China Boy" by Gus Lee. Toussaint plays the role of the protector.

1) He taught Kai how to live life on the streets
2) Toussaint let Kai joined the Y even though the membership to join. Toussaint doesn't expect much from Kai because he knows how it feels to be the one left out, so he takes Kai in like a little brother.
3) Toussaint protects Kai by teaching him the way of life in the streets, which makes Kai's life easier than it was before.

Michael Qi

9/24/2013 01:04:09 am

Wow Judy! China Boy sounds like a great book the way you presented information about Toussaint definitely makes me want to read this book to read more about his generosity.

Victor H. Period 5

9/21/2013 07:50:21 am

In the book The Help by Kathryn Stockett, Miss Skeeter plays the role of the protector.

1. Miss Skeeter is the protector in this story. She wants to protect the black people or the help. She was raised by a help that supported her and loved her. She has a lot of respect for black people, and she wants to help them achieve equality and no longer be subjected and discriminated by black people.

2. Living in a segregation dominated town, Jackson, Mississippi, she is in a very bad position to help black people. Everyone in her town is against equal rights for black people. However, she subtly gathers stories to write a book about the struggles of black people. She tries her best to gather the helps in secret to write down their stories. She does this without any of her white friends knowing. She does not give up on collecting her stories to achieve her dreams as a writer but at the same time helping blacks gain equality.

3. How does the protector PROTECT? State at least two examples that you've read about so far?
Miss Skeeter protects by talking to Aibileen and apologizing for the harsh things she has to hear at the meetings about separate toilets. Miss Skeeter cares and tries to protect the feelings of Aibileen. Miss Sketeter also tries to protect Yule when Miss Hilly inquired what Yule is doing. She protects the helps by trying to a book to reveal the struggles black maids go through to serve white people.

Marissa C., Period 6

9/21/2013 08:52:42 am

I am reading "The Help" by Kathryn Stockett and I feel that the protector is Miss Skeeter.

1. Miss Skeeter is tender towards the help in that she genuinely cares about their feelings. She is constantly worrying about making Aibileen feel comfortable in her presence, and takes certain measures to make sure that Aibileen feels as though she can trust her.

2. Miss Skeeter's weakness is that she longs to know about the mysterious disappearance of her old maid, Constantine. She is tender to this weakness in that every chance she gets, she asks Aibileen what she might know about what happened to Constantine. Skeeter also tries inquiring about the firing of the maid to both of her parents, however, to no avail.

3. Miss Skeeter protects in that she puts off publishing the Home Health Sanitation issue for as long as she can, so as not to offend the colored help or hurt their feelings. In taking such a huge risk with writing the book on the help, Skeeter also works to protect the help by changing their identities, while trying to work to protect their rights as citizens.

Yela M., Period 5

9/22/2013 06:51:16 am

Tweak by Nic Sheff:

1. Nic is tender towards his girlfriend Lauren because when she got a seizure from the drugs, he couldn't help himself but try to save her by doing CPR and calling the police. He ended up saving Lauren's life and she was able to stay alive till the ambulance came.

2. Nic knows that it's really wrong to steal from people he knows. However, he feels guilty for stealing it. He also tried to change his lifestyle by quitting his drug addiction, and saving money to invest in something worthwhile.

3. Nic protects others more than himself. He cares for his girlfriend, Lauren, and he cares for his family. He protects his girlfriend from almost dying when he shot up drugs in her system, and he protects his family from not being in contact with them because he didn't want them to worry so much, and have his siblings get influenced by him.

Jeny C., Per.5

9/22/2013 11:23:01 am

I am reading THE GLASS CASTLE by Jeannette Walls. The protectors in this book are Jeannette and Brian.

1. Jeannette Walls is tender towards the other characters by giving them what they want despite the circumstances. For example, her father spends crucial money on booze. When Jeannette is finally handling the money she made sure that there was enough money to feed the entire family for the month. However, when her father asked her money for booze, she hesitantly gave him the money, despite the tight budget.
2. Jeannette's weakness is her father. Her father is the one person she cannot neglect, despite the circumstances. She desperately attempts to persuade her father to halt his drinking, yet fails.
3. i.
Jeannette protects by trying to find food for her family. Although she is only a child, she knows that her parents aren't going to provide for the family, so her and Brian go an expeditions scavenging for food.
ii.
Jeannette saves up money for her sister to go to New York, to protect her from the lunatics she calls family, so she can become someone who can support herself.

John H. Per. 5

9/22/2013 11:58:28 am

In my book "China Boy" buy Gus Lee, I feel that the protector is Toussaint.
Toussaint understands that Kai can not protect himself when others pick on him so Toussaint befriends him and tries to help Kai learn to protect himself.
Toussaint knows that his family doesn't have that much money, but like his mother, he shares what he has with the people around him and Kai. Since he also doesn't have a father, he makes one up from listening to Kai describe how nice his own father is which makes Toussaint happy.
Toussaint protects Kai by trying to teach him how to defend himself against the other boys in the neighborhood. He also is the first friend of Kai. This is protecting Kai because it gives Kai a feeling that someone has his back and would help him whenever he is in need.

Garin L. Period 1

9/22/2013 12:01:23 pm

I am reading the book "The Stranger" by Albert Camus. I feel that Marie Cardona is the protector in this book.

1. Marie and Meursault have a thing for each other and Marie is there for Meursault.

2. Marie supports Meursault when he gets arrested and supports him through his trial as well.

3.Marie gives Meursault company after Meursault's death. She even wants to be his wife.

Stephanie Wong

9/22/2013 01:11:22 pm

My Literature Circle book is The Book Thief, by Markus Zusak.

Hans Hubermann plays the role of a protector in The Book Thief. He is an important role model for Liesel.

1.Unlike his wife Rosa Hubermann, Hans Hubermann protects and comforts Liesel when she has nightmares at night. He helps her through this every night, even if it means losing sleep. He is projected to be the protector when he first comforted Liesel in the beginning of the book.

2.Hans Hubermann cares too little for his opinion about his own life; he always obey his wife’s orders and opinions. For example, although he enjoys playing the piano accordion for money, he doesn’t because his wife is unhappy about it.

3. As a protector, he shows selfless behavior towards Liesel. An example is when he comforts her at night. He is the first person to teach Liesel to read. He reads with her every night after she awakes from her nightmares.

Stephanie Wong, Period 01

9/22/2013 01:20:17 pm

My Literature Circle book is The Book Thief, by Markus Zusak.

Hans Hubermann plays the role of a protector in The Book Thief. He is an important role model for Liesel.

1.Unlike his wife Rosa Hubermann, Hans Hubermann protects and comforts Liesel when she has nightmares at night. He helps her through this every night, even if it means losing sleep. He is projected to be the protector when he first comforted Liesel in the beginning of the book.

2.Hans Hubermann cares too little for his opinion about his own life; he always obey his wife’s orders and opinions. For example, although he enjoys playing the piano accordion for money, he doesn’t because his wife is unhappy about it.

3.As a protector, he shows selfless behavior towards Liesel. An example is when he comforts her at night. He is the first person to teach Liesel to read. He reads with her every night after she awakes from her nightmares.

Caitlin Lian Eckvahl, Period 2

9/22/2013 01:22:39 pm

The book I'm reading in my literature circle is "The Help", by Kathryn Stockett, and I think that Miss Skeeter is the protector.

1. I think that Miss Skeeter is tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters by being patient with them. When she asks Aibleen and the other maids if she can interview them, she doesn't immediately expect them to say yes to her seemingly ridiculous request. She makes them feel comfortable when she interviews them, and genuinely cares for their safety and well being.

2. Skeeter's weakness is that she is eager for information, she constantly asks Aibleen what happened to her late maid Constantine, but she must resist her natural instincts to uncover the ugly truth.

3. Skeeter protects the maids by messing up Hilly's Home Help Sanitation plan in the League newsletter. She also protects the help by taking extra precautions when visiting Aibleen for interviews.

Derrick L. Period 1

9/22/2013 01:25:48 pm

I am reading The Stranger by Albert Camus and I feel that the protector is Monsieur Meursault.

1. Throughout the book Monsieur Meursault is tender towards others by helping anyone having trouble with something. He also is very welcoming to anyone he comes across.

2. Meursault is tender towards his own weaknesses by avoiding any emotion that comes to him. When thoughts of his dead mother comes up he changes his thoughts to another subject.

3.One of the ways Monsieur Meursault protects is by helping a guy named Raymond kill a man that was after him. However, Monsieur Meursault barely knew Raymond for a few days. Another way Monsieur Meursault protects is by helping out his neighbor by telling him where his lost dog can be.

Stephanie Wong, Period 06

9/22/2013 01:30:45 pm

My Literature Circle book is The Book Thief, by Markus Zusak.

Hans Hubermann plays the role of a protector in The Book Thief. He is an important role model for Liesel.

1.Unlike his wife Rosa Hubermann, Hans Hubermann protects and comforts Liesel when she has nightmares at night. He helps her through this every night, even if it means losing sleep. He is projected to be the protector when he first comforted Liesel in the beginning of the book.

2.Hans Hubermann cares too little for his opinion about his own life; he always obey his wife’s orders and opinions. For example, although he enjoys playing the piano accordion for money, he doesn’t because his wife is unhappy about it.

3.As a protector, he shows selfless behavior towards Liesel. An example is when he comforts her at night. He is the first person to teach Liesel to read. He reads with her every night after she awakes from her nightmares.

Christine Lee Period 6

9/22/2013 04:32:20 pm

In "The Book Thief" by Markus Zusak, Hans Hubermann is the true protector throughout the book. He protects Liesel as a father and teaches her how to read.
1. How is the protector tender toward the weaknesses in the other characters?
When Liesel is not feeling happy or she's upset, Hans seems to comfort her like a loving father.
2. How is the protector tender toward his/her own weakness?
He puts everyone else before himself. He puts Liesel first before himself because she is his adopted daughter and he loves her.
3. How does the protector PROTECT? State at least two examples that you've read about so far?
Hans protects Liesel by comforting her. Whenever Liesel has a nightmare or she wets her bed, he stays with her until she can sleep and comforts her. He also makes sure Max is safe since he is hiding from the Nazi Party.

Stephany F., period 2

9/22/2013 09:44:06 pm

The book my literature circle is reading is called “Sarah’s Key” and it was written by Tatiana de Rosnay. The characters that I think play the role of protectors are Jules and Genevieve.

1. Jules and Genevieve are an elderly couple that found and gave refuge to Sarah and Rachel. After they managed to escape from Auschwitz, the girls needed a place to hide from the authorities. The couple took them in as their own, along with other Jewish children, and tried to give them as much of a comfortable life as possible.

2. Jules and Genevieve were farmers. This is a clear indication that they probably weren't the richest people ever, maybe not even close to being in the middle-class level. They most likely struggled to put food on the table daily, and had to work very hard to earn their money. Nevertheless, they still took in quite a few Jewish children and gave them shelter, on top of having kids of their own. They were genuinely humble people, and tried to put others before themselves, regardless of their own weaknesses.

3. The fact that Jules and Genevieve took in Sarah and Rachel in the first place labels them as protectors. They hid them from the Gestapo and took care of them like they were their own children. Nobody forced them, and they could have turned their backs to these Jewish children, but they didn't. Not only that, but when Rachel got sick, they called a Nazi doctor to see what was wrong with the little girl. They tried to do everything they possibly could to try and save her life, even if it meant getting caught by the Nazi officials. Both of these instances demonstrate that Jules and Genevieve protected Rachel and Sarah from beginning to end. If it wasn't for their kind hearts, these kids would not have gone far at all, and Sarah would not have been able to go back to Paris for her brother.

Rainie X., per 1

9/23/2013 02:41:24 am

Rainie X., Per 109/20/2013 7:55pm
The literature circle book that I am reading is "The Glass Castle", by Jeannette Walls. I think the protector is Brain.

1. Brain is the only son in the Walls family. Although he is the second youngest, he always try his best to help his parents and sisters. He shows his care and love when his family gets into trouble. When Jeannette was in trouble, he was the one that most likely to help her.

2. Brain's weakness is that he can not always be there, and he is too young. Sometimes, he can not even protect himself. For example, when Grandma Erma tried to doing something that she should not do to him( Grandma Erma is pervert), he could not even fight back.

3. Brain protected Jeannette when she was beat by three Mexicans girls that were jealous about Jeannette's intelligence. Also, Brain protected Lori and Jeanette when Billy shot them with the BB gun. He tried his best to take care of the girls, and tried his best to be a mature boy.

Shirley H., Period 2

9/23/2013 04:14:58 pm

I am reading Sarah's Key by Tatiana de Rosnay and I think an example of a protector is the policeman who helps Sarah and Rachel.

1. Even though he could be arrested for helping them, the policeman helps Sarah and Rachel escape the camp and even gave them some money.

2. He is afraid to help them because being caught will mean his own ruin. Nonetheless, he gets over it and helps them leave.

3. He protected Sarah and Rachel by letting them escape and providing them with money. He protected Sarah while she was walking across the street. He again protected them by helping them escape from the Nazis.

Michael Qi

9/24/2013 12:58:41 am

The book that I am reading is The Stranger by Albert Camus. The protector in this story is Monsieur Meursault.

1. Meursault feels no emotions so he tends towards other people's weaknesses by listening to them and do what they tell him to do.

2.One of Meursault's weaknesses is that his mother passed away and whenever someone wants to talk about it or mentions it, Meursault looks the other way and ignores it.

3. Meursault protected his mother by protecting her dignity. He kept quiet about her when people talked about her when she passed away. Meursault also protected shintes by helping him beat up someone.

Justin Saisho

9/24/2013 02:06:42 am

In the Catcher in the Rye, Mr. Spencer is the person i believe plays the protector.

1. Mr. Spencer always puts Holden on a high pedestal. He believes he's destined to be a good kid.

2. Mr. Spencer is an old man and can't do much. He's doing as much as he can so that holden won't fail anyone anymore.

3. Mr. Spencer called holden over so that he could talk about school. Holden is struggling, but Mr. Spencer believes that Holden could bounce back and start doing well in school. He is a really caring person.

Kalvin L. Period 2

9/25/2013 02:26:14 am

My literature circle book is "Ender's Game" it is a story about a genius child name Ender who has been chosen by the military to be trained and become the military commander that will save the human race from an alien invasion.

The protector in the story is Ender's sister Valentine. She tries to shield Ender from Peter's (Ender's older brother) abusive behavior and death threats. She also gives Ender emotional support by telling him that he is nothing like Peter.

Rico L. P.2

9/25/2013 02:29:55 am

Ender's Game-Orson Scott
Protector:Valentine
1. Valentine is tender toward others weaknesses by telling Ender that he can always come back to her if he was breaking apart since battle school was beginning to be too much for him.

2. She is tender towards her own weaknesses by doing what she can and admitting that she cannot do some things.

3. Valentine protects Ender from the harshness of Peter and the battle school. She protects him by gathering evidence about Peter's mistakes and threatening to use it against him if he ever harmed her or Ender. She also protects the colonists moving to the bugger world in the end of the book. She does this by becoming their leader and helping them build a new community.

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.

Literature Circles Forum

Literature Circle Post #3: Describe a character who is a protector!

Leave a Reply.

Author

Archives

Categories